Back in 1966, Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys decided that he no longer wanted to tour with the band, instead wanting to concentrate on composition. The band needed someone to fill in on bass and the ridiculously high harmonies usually supplied by Brian for an upcoming tour of Japan. They found a man who was born in Arkansas to fulfill the task, but he only lasted on that one tour. This same man went on to record with a studio band named Sagittarius, before littering the pop and country charts for many years afterward with assorted hits under his own name: Glen Campbell.

Tomorrow night in Milwaukee, I am going to see Glen Campbell perform in concert, but the occasion will more than likely be bittersweet. The man who has given his music to the world for a majority of my lifetime is on his final tour, having recently been diagnosed as being in the early stages of Alzheimer’s Disease. It is not lost on me that all of the facts in the above paragraph, which my lifetime of music as a hobby has allowed me to commit to memory, will someday be foreign to the very person who made them possible.

As someone who has been involved with the health care industry for over 20 years, I have learned that based on the sheer volume of facts that inundate me on a daily basis, it has become nearly impossible for me to forget key elements of my job. As the cost of health care has become a central focus for cuts in a post-war economy, a number of  memories of failed policies of the past are skipping to the front of my mental line. Nowhere is this memory more acute that in the realm of physician reimbursement from the Medicare program.

Forty-one days from now, a song-and-dance act that has been running longer than Cats will repeat itself, as the increasingly polarized sides of our government once again raise the curtain on this year’s performance of Doc Fix. There are slight casting changes with every performance, but the script is the same. In the torch-lit Temple of SGR, an automated computer program threatens to take money away from the white-coated sailors on the HMS Doctor. As the sailors fight off armies of infirmed elderly waving checkbooks from behind the wheels of their Buicks, an unlikely set of heroes, wearing bad suits and American Flag lapel pins, short circuit the program with a stack of paper. As they stand in the setting sun, they promise to one day rid the world of the computer, but vow to be ready for anything else it plans to offer.

Oklahoma it ain’t……

Medicare reimbursement has gone from “pay everything” at the beginning of the program in 1966, to RBRVS and Gramm-Rudman-Hollings reductions in the ’80’s, subsequently to SGR in the late ’90’s, and finally to a yearly hostage crisis, with the only missing element seemingly being the security camera shot of Patty Hearst with a machine gun. We know this because it has affected us all in one form or another over the years and we have internalized the memories of the negative results of every one of these “solutions”.

Might I suggest that the solution doesn’t lie with finding a new payment methodology, but in finding savings from outside contractors for the Medicare program that (because I have it committed to memory) continuously take money needlessly from the program.

You can start by eliminating Medicare Part C. Virtually all of the “preventive benefits” offered to patients under these plans are now codified into traditional Medicare, which leaves Medicare Part C as nothing more than a government subsidy designed to prop up the insurance industry with billions of dollars that it doesn’t require for its survival.

Next we can go to Average Wholesale Price for reimbursement under Medicare Part D, rather than Average Sale Price. Additionally, pick one formulary and take the program out of many of the same hands that currently pollute Medicare Part C.

As for fraud investigations, leave in place predictive modeling and the HEAT teams, because these methods are actually getting to the root of the problem and are returning ill-gotten dollars to the Medicare program. When it comes to outside entities, we need not develop memories of the Recovery Audit  Contractors, because their abhorrent work product is currently on display for all the world to see. Roughly 2/3rds of everything they do is dedicated to purposeless paper shuffling, rather than the detection of actual improper payments. One marvels at the thought of the massive celebrations that would result if the RACs suddenly disappeared. Farther up the chain, the ZPICs on average collect about 2% of everything they extrapolate as an overpayment, but we don’t really know the actual number because the OIG has stated that the baseline data to measure their performance is fatally flawed. This reminds me that until that data is purified, the ZPICs will continue to mainly operate as a middle man for government-sponsored subsidies to the legal industry. Ask your typical taxpayer if that is something they wish to continue.

The development of the human memory keeps one from being fascinated by the latest shiny pocket watch issue being pendulated in our faces by the self-absorbed politician of the moment. Much like Glen Campbell, there may come a day that the many facts parading in our minds will begin to slip away. Until that day comes, in the realm of health care, memories are not just a rudimentary tool of assistance, but a blunt weapon against the many forces attempting to shove unwelcome schemes into an arena currently collapsing from the bad ideas of the past.

Paul Spencer will be a presenter at the Fi-Med RAC Summit in Milwaukee, WI on April 16th and 17th, 2012. Go to the Summit website for further information on this unique educational opportunity. Use promo code “SPENCER” to receive $50 off the registration price for a limited time.